ThinkCivics News
An educated citizenry is a vital requisite
for our survival as a free people.
Join ThinkCivics+
  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Health
  • US News
  • Faith
  • Science & Tech
  • World News
No Result
View All Result
ThinkCivics News
  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Health
  • US News
  • Faith
  • Science & Tech
  • World News
Join ThinkCivics+
No Result
View All Result
ThinkCivics News
Join TC+
Home Culture & Society Education

5 Reasons Joe Biden Can’t Force Taxpayers To Pay Other People’s Student Loans

The Federalist by The Federalist
May 2, 2022
in Education
Reading Time: 5 mins read
0
0
5 Reasons Joe Biden Can’t Force Taxpayers To Pay Other People’s Student Loans

MOBILUS IN MOBILI / FLICKR / CC BY-SA 2.0

On April 25, President Joe Biden gave his strongest indication yet that he would unilaterally force taxpayers to pay off other people’s student loans. Biden is hopeful to restore his dire approval rating among young people, 85 percent of whom apparently want other people to pay for their personal spending. What politician could resist giving out other people’s money?

Let’s put aside for a second that forgiving student loans is a regressive wealth transfer, unfair to past loan holders, an inflation bomb, and incentivizes colleges to raise tuition even higher. There’s another real problem—the administration has no legal authority to pursue its punishment of the working class in favor of lawyers, doctors, and unemployed art history PhDs.

When our founders gave the president the authority to command the Army and receive ambassadors, they never mentioned the president’s student loan forgiveness powers. So, he can only take this action if Congress has authorized it. Congress hasn’t.

1. You Can’t Forgive Loans You Don’t Own

Proponents of nationalizing $1.75 trillion in student debt claim the U.S. secretary of education has the power to absorb such debt pursuant to the Higher Education Act of 1965. This act set up a public-private loan program where the federal government didn’t directly own any student’s loan. Rather, private lenders lent money to students at capped rates, in exchange for the federal government backing the loans.

These government-backed loans had specific terms on deferment, default, and repayment. For example, if the borrower served in the Peace Corps, the borrower could defer paying principal (but interest would accrue) for up to three years. Also, for students whose families made less than $15,000 per year, the government would pay a portion of the interest.

In addition, Congress provided general authorities to the secretary of education to oversee the program, including that the secretary may “enforce, pay, compromise, waive, or release any right, title, claim, lien, or demand, however acquired, including any equity or any right or redemption.”

Today, this catch-all provision is cited by big-government advocates like Sen. Elizabeth Warren to authorize the secretary of education to force taxpayers to assume all student loans. But it could not have worked to do this when drafted and passed, as the federal government was unable to “compromise” debt it didn’t own. The Higher Education Act held the federal government responsible for owning the debt if the loan was in default, after a set period of time.

2. Congress Gets Specific Without Loan Bailouts

Later developments make the federal loan bailout case even more difficult. Fast-forward to 1992: Congress granted specific loan flexibility to students experiencing financial hardship by allowing for up to three years of principal deferment. Congress clearly articulated that “economic hardship” meant making minimum wage or living at 100 percent of the poverty line for a family of two.

Fast-forward again to 2003, when Congress passed another specific law, following the attack on 9/11, to provide the secretary flexibility to provide forbearance and occasionally cancellation, but only to “affected” students, meaning students who joined the military or who were harmed by a national emergency.

Under President Barack Obama in 2010—hilariously to “pay for” Obamacare—the public-private loan system was subbed out for one of direct government loans, and the secretary’s broad powers to oversee the program carried over. But words only have meaning in context, and for five reasons, Congress undeniably did not give the secretary blanket bailout power. Not in 1965, not in 1992, not in 2003, and not today.

3. When Congress Writes Clearly, Its Words Have Meaning

First, standard legal interpretation requires that specific provisions be given effect over more general provisions. That is, if Congress took the time to define how and when the secretary can forgive loans, we use that specific provision to interpret the secretary’s power, not the general authorization.

Second, and relatedly, another basic interpretative tool is that a statute should be read to give effect to every provision, not to render certain provisions meaningless. Forcing taxpayers to assume student debt would, in effect, delete multiple provisions governing the student loan system. Such a reading cannot be squared with Congress passing multiple, unique limitations on the secretary’s loan forgiveness authority.

4. If No-Questions-Asked Loan Forgiveness Actually Existed, You Would Know

Third, a statute must be read with a lens of reasonableness, recognizing that Congress does not “hide elephants in mouseholes.” Congress does not secretly give a sweeping power that changes the fundamental details of a regulatory scheme, just like no nationwide vaccine mandate authority was hidden in a workplace safety rule.

Not only would the 1965 Congress be shocked to know today’s proposed interpretation, given the public-private scheme back then, but more importantly, mass forgiveness would not have been a possible interpretation.

5. No One Is Above the Law

Fourth, under our system of constitutional governance, presidents lack “dispensing” authority, that is, the power to override the law in the interests of justice. That’s with good reason: If an executive official can bypass specific prohibitions in the law, based on a vague reference to a broad authority, our country risks transforming into exactly the monarchical dispensation system our founders sought to avoid.

Fifth, agencies, by law, cannot spend money they don’t have and must try and collect on debts owed to the U.S. government. The Antideficiency Act, for example, captures the seriousness by which Congress regards its constitutional power over the budget, by holding federal employees personally and criminally responsible for spending funds not appropriated.

The Congressional Budget Office in 2010 predicted that the student loan system would earn the government $68 billion over ten years, which eliminates the idea that Biden can spend $2 trillion in loan bailouts. As related to debts owed the federal government, “Federal agencies shall aggressively collect all debts arising out of activities of, or referred or transferred for collection services to, that agency.”

The Obvious: The Loans Aren’t Working

In sum, there is no secretive student loan “delete” button. This is not to say our student loan system isn’t tragic: it is tragic. The system operates exactly contrary to basic lending principles, leaving the Department of Education with so much debt that it represented 84 percent of our gross domestic product in 2017.

And all this debt has gotten us nowhere. Since 1965, the percentage of young people in the bottom income quartile who have attained a bachelor’s degree has barely budged, from 6 to 11 percent.  Meanwhile, the average debt owed per loan holder since just 2007 has skyrocketed 229 percent.

The real problem is that federal student subsidies are causing college to become unaffordable and many graduates cannot find jobs. The cost of college has more than doubled since 1964, after adjusting for inflation, and the source of colleges’ revenue is increasingly tuition. This means colleges are consciously raising their costs, knowing students will just borrow larger and larger amounts.

When a student gets to college, the college also has no financial incentive to equip her for success. So if she ends up unemployed and defaults on her loan, the college gets paid in full by the taxpayers regardless. This is no way to help the poor—by encouraging them to take on debt and attend an institution (literally) uninvested in their future.

Universities Need Skin in the Game

If our politicians really want to bail out student loans, how about this—make the universities pay half. Some people object to such reforming, claiming that tying the universities to the success of their students will shut down universities that “serve” low-income communities.

But no college should be rewarded for loading first-generation college students up with debt, providing a watered-down education, and wiping their hands of them. If we have fewer, but more dedicated colleges paired with new, innovative post-high school options that actually lead to good-paying jobs, our nation will be a more prosperous place.

Authored by May Davis via The Federalist 

The Federalist

The Federalist is an online magazine that covers politics, policy, culture, and religion.

thefederalist.com
Tags: AcadamiaBailoutscollegeHigher educationstudent debtStudent loans

Related Posts

School district files ‘sexual harassment’ complaint against 3 middle school students for using the wrong pronouns

School district files ‘sexual harassment’ complaint against 3 middle school students for using the wrong pronouns

May 14, 2022
Teachers brag about ignoring parent requests to use children’s birth name, pronouns

Teachers brag about ignoring parent requests to use children’s birth name, pronouns

May 12, 2022

Public Schools’ Removal Of Advanced Courses Cultivates Mediocrity In The Name Of Equity

May 12, 2022

Whistleblower Confirms: FBI Targeting Parents Under Counter-Terrorism Provisions

May 12, 2022
Load More
Next Post
Doocy Bombs Psaki Over ‘Disinformation Board’ Head Spreading Disinformation, Biden Wanting to Censor Opinions

Doocy Bombs Psaki Over 'Disinformation Board' Head Spreading Disinformation, Biden Wanting to Censor Opinions

BREAKING: Supreme Court Will Strike Down Roe v. Wade, According to Draft Opinion

BREAKING: Supreme Court Will Strike Down Roe v. Wade, According to Draft Opinion

Hundreds Of Protesters Were Ready With Signs Outside Supreme Court Following Unprecedented Leak Of Draft Roe Opinion

Hundreds Of Protesters Were Ready With Signs Outside Supreme Court Following Unprecedented Leak Of Draft Roe Opinion

TODAY'S TOP STORIES

  • White House Admits It Lied About Vaccines

    White House Admits It Lied About Vaccines

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Surprise! America’s ‘leading cause of death’ identified

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Legacy Media Credibility Takes Another Hit as Major Rumor About Justice Alito Is Confirmed

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • COVID Vaccine Bombshells You Probably Missed

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Must-Read: Abbott Fires Back After Alarming Psaki Claim About Their Baby Formula

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

The most disturbing thing about Biden’s new Minister of Truth that the media is not telling you

by ThinkCivics Newswire
May 10, 2022
0
The most disturbing thing about Biden’s new Minister of Truth that the media is not telling you
National Security

The Biden Administration’s new “Disinformation Governance Board” has mostly attracted attention for the ridiculous Harry Potter/Mary Poppins superfan chosen to...

Read more

This little-known nation could be China’s perfect wedge to overtake the USA

by ThinkCivics Newswire
May 7, 2022
0
This little-known nation could be China’s perfect wedge to overtake the USA
National Security

We've got a problem in our own back patio.  Actually, we have our own Ukraine, complete with Russian tanks, China jockeying for...

Read more

Claim: Trump Secretly Wanted To Bomb Cartel Drug Labs In Mexico

by The Political Insider
May 7, 2022
0
Claim: Trump Secretly Wanted To Bomb Cartel Drug Labs In Mexico
National Security

Former Secretary of Defense Mark Esper claims Donald Trump inquired on at least two occasions about secretly bombing illegal cartel...

Read more

6 Dystopian Things Biden’s ‘Disinformation Board’ Pick Nina Jankowicz Has Done

by The Federalist
May 4, 2022
0
6 Dystopian Things Biden’s ‘Disinformation Board’ Pick Nina Jankowicz Has Done
National Security

Mere days after eccentric billionaire Elon Musk’s buyout of Twitter sent the political censors into a tizzy, the Biden administration...

Read more
Bezos Goes After Biden Again on Twitter, Busting Him Bad
Economy

Bezos Goes After Biden Again on Twitter, Busting Him Bad

by ThinkCivics Newswire
May 15, 2022
0

We may be seeing the beginning of the elite throwing Joe Biden under the bus. I wrote on Saturday about...

Read more
Economists at Federal Reserve bank debunk popular Dem narrative about record-high gas prices
Economy

Economists at Federal Reserve bank debunk popular Dem narrative about record-high gas prices

by The Blaze
May 13, 2022
0

Economists at the Federal Reserve of Dallas published analysis this week debunking a popular claim that Democrats make against oil companies. What...

Read more
Biden Administration’s Response and Priorities re: Baby Formula Shortage Are Disturbingly out of Whack
Economy

Biden Administration’s Response and Priorities re: Baby Formula Shortage Are Disturbingly out of Whack

by RedState
May 12, 2022
0

There’s currently a nationwide shortage of baby formula. That’s making some families desperate to find it for their babies. Fox’s...

Read more
Joe Biden Has Another Old Man Meltdown, Starts Yelling About Food Shortages Happening While He’s President
Economy

Joe Biden Has Another Old Man Meltdown, Starts Yelling About Food Shortages Happening While He’s President

by ThinkCivics Newswire
May 12, 2022
0

Reset the "days since" calendar. Joe Biden had another old man meltdown, two months to the day of his last classic...

Read more
Facebook Twitter RSS

Brilliantly

SAFE!

thinkcivics.com

Content & Links

Verified by Sur.ly

2022

Recent News

  • Fauci: I will quit if Trump is reelected
  • 5 Lies Abortion Supporters Spread About Overturning Roe And How To Counter Them
  • The Latest Instance of Joe Biden’s Handlers Running Interference Is Maximum Cringe

Category

  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Editorials
  • Education
  • Elections
  • Energy
  • Environment
  • Faith
  • Health
  • Immigration
  • Military
  • National Security
  • Politics
  • Science & Tech
  • US News
  • Videos
  • World News

© 2022 ThinkCivics Media. All Rights Reserved.

  • Login
  • Sign Up
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About
  • Store
  • Contact Us
  • Join
  • Contribute

© 2022 ThinkCivics Media. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

OR

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.