ThinkCivics News
An educated citizenry is a vital requisite
for our survival as a free people.
Join ThinkCivics+
  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Health
  • US News
  • Faith
  • Science & Tech
  • World News
No Result
View All Result
ThinkCivics News
  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Health
  • US News
  • Faith
  • Science & Tech
  • World News
Join ThinkCivics+
No Result
View All Result
ThinkCivics News
Join TC+
Home Health

Bioethicist: Let Doctors Kill the Healthy by Harvesting Organs

National Review by National Review
August 21, 2021
in Health
Reading Time: 4 mins read
0
0
Bioethicist: Let Doctors Kill the Healthy by Harvesting Organs

A hospital in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada, November 2, 2020 (Shannon VanRaes/Reuters)

We have entered the era of what I call “do harm medicine,” in which the concept of what constitutes harming the patient has become entirely malleable and subjective. I even wrote a book covering that subject.

Here’s an example: When organ transplant medicine began, the “dead donor rule” was instituted to assure a wary public that people’s vital organs would only be procured after the person was dead. A corollary to that rule assures the public that people will not be killed for their body parts.

The dead-donor rule has been under attack for some time within the utilitarian bioethics movement. (I am not writing about the brain-death controversy, which is a separate discussion.) Many bioethicists are now pushing to allow doctors to kill via organ harvest, sometimes called “organ donation euthanasia” (ODE).

At first, this proposed killing license was supposed to be limited to patients on the verge of death or the permanently unconscious. Now, a prominent bioethics journal has published a piece urging that healthy people be allowed to die by removal of vital organs.

The author claims that because people can instruct life-sustaining treatment to be withdrawn (LST), and can donate their organs after death, that ODE is also OK because it will result in death, too, and result in more usable organs procured and more lives saved. From, “May I Give My Heart Away?: On the Permissibility of Living Vital Organ Donation:”

In this situation, according to proponents of ODE, the doctor should respect the decision, even when this will cause the death of the patient. It seems commonly accepted that patient autonomy allows patients to refuse any medical intervention initiated on one’s body and life, and therefore, doctors are morally obligated to withdraw LST when this is what the patient wants. If we should uphold the DDR in such situations, the doctor should wait until the patient is declared dead to procure the patient’s organs.

Proponents of ODE argue that if the patient consents, it would be permissible to procure the patient’s organs before death. This will of course mean that the patient will die from donating his or her vital organs instead of dying from having his or her treatment withdrawn. However, this seems ethically immaterial in this situation since the outcome for the patient will be the same.

But that’s not true. Not everyone dies after having life-sustaining treatment withdrawn. Indeed, under current organ-donation protocols, if the patient doesn’t die, he is taken back to the ward and usually disqualified as an organ donor thereafter.

Once death ceases to be the necessary predicate for donating vital organs — and is replaced with “consent” — there would be no natural limiting principle. And so it is here. Rather than being a form of euthanasia to end suffering, the idea is to permit someone to have themselves killed for the altruistic purpose of saving other people’s lives, called living vital organ donation (LVOD). All that matters would be consent, and moreover, such a program would allow for tailored killing by harvesting:

If the autonomous desire to sacrifice oneself to benefit others should count as a morally relevant reason, all things being equal, this desire will have a greater chance of being fulfilled when the donor is not imminently dying. In such cases, the donation can be postponed until a suitable recipient is in place. By contrast, when the primary motivation is death, as it is in ODE, it is plausible that patients would not be willing or able to wait for months, maybe years, until a receiver match appears.

But consent has the power to justify abundant “do harm” medical practices. Example, policies that allowed sex-change surgeries for the few have now expanded to validate puberty blocking for children, for which there is scant evidence of benefit and the potential for material physical harm. Look ma, no brakes!

Besides, once a fundamental moral principle is breached, it is like a dam breaking. The deluge may begin as a trickle, but soon the reservoir empties flooding the plains below. Hence:

  • Assisted suicide/euthanasia for the terminally ill who ask to die was legalized as a means to prevent suffering at the end of life.
  • That morphed in some places into allowing people with disabilities and chronic conditions who ask to die to be killed to eliminate suffering.
  • Which morphed into allowing the mentally ill who ask to die to be killed in some jurisdictions to eliminate suffering.
  • Which morphed into conjoining organ harvesting with euthanasia (in the Netherlands, Belgium, and Canada) if the person to be killed consents.
  • Which morphed into several proposals to permit killing by organ harvesting for those facing imminent death.
  • Which has now morphed into a proposal to allow healthy people to ask to be killed for altruistic reasons.
  • Which will one day morph into proposals to allow surrogates to authorize euthanasia via organ harvesting for the incapacitated or letting people order themselves harvested once they become incapacitated in advance medical directives.

Please understand that these proposals are not fringe ideas. Bioethics, which published this article,is a wholly mainstream publication. The idea of killing for organs is considered respectable in the field. And it gives these advocates no pause that their plans would also transform organ-transplant doctors — known for focusing exclusively on saving lives — into outright killers.

The only way I can think of to thwart this drip-drip-drip-into-deluge process is to cast a bright light on where the thought leaders in bioethics want to take health-care policy in coming years. Forewarned, I hope, is forearmed. Hopefully, the people upon whom these policies would be imposed will disagree and thwart the best-laid plans of utilitarians and bioethicists.

This article was originally published by National Review. Read the original article.

National Review

National Review is an American conservative editorial magazine, focusing on news and commentary pieces on political, social, and cultural affairs.

www.nationalreview.com/
Tags: BioethicistDoctorsMedicineODEOrgans

Related Posts

Shock Video: ‘Covid Critical’ ‘To Legitimize Total Biometric Surveillance’

Shock Video: ‘Covid Critical’ ‘To Legitimize Total Biometric Surveillance’

May 25, 2022
Documents from 2021 int’l security exercise showed monkeypox bio attack on May 15, 2022

Documents from 2021 int’l security exercise showed monkeypox bio attack on May 15, 2022

May 23, 2022

Belgium Begins Monkeypox Quarantines, Biden Warns “Everybody Should Be Concerned”

May 22, 2022

‘Imagine The Compliance’: Pfizer CEO Pitches Davos Elites On WiFi Microchip Pills

May 21, 2022
Load More
Next Post
Top Taliban leader has arrived in Kabul for talks on forming a new government

Top Taliban leader has arrived in Kabul for talks on forming a new government

Gen Z is made of zombies — less educated, more depressed, without values

Gen Z is made of zombies — less educated, more depressed, without values

Afghanistan proves our failed generals no longer care about winning

Afghanistan proves our failed generals no longer care about winning

TODAY'S TOP STORIES

  • Protesters block, attack truck and horse trailer, driver runs them over

    Protesters block, attack truck and horse trailer, driver runs them over

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Unvaccinated People Will Be Barred From This, Starting May 31

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Watch As Nancy Pelosi Has Meltdown During Live Interview To Roe v. Wade Question

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Here’s a Three-Word Policy That’s Been Effective in Stopping School Shootings

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Report: Police Got Own Kids Out of School While Subduing Other Uvalde Parents

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

WHO withdraws 12 Biden ‘sovereignty’ amendments amid fierce opposition

by ThinkCivics Newswire
May 27, 2022
0
WHO withdraws 12 Biden ‘sovereignty’ amendments amid fierce opposition
National Security

Amid charges of ceding U.S. sovereignty to the World Health Organization, 12 of the 13 amendments submitted by the Biden administration...

Read more

Newly obtained memo shows John Kerry was conducting ‘secret’ meetings with Iran during the Trump administration

by ThinkCivics Newswire
May 26, 2022
0
Newly obtained memo shows John Kerry was conducting ‘secret’ meetings with Iran during the Trump administration
National Security

This article was originally published on Twitchy.com. Read the original article.

Read more

Handwritten Notes From 2017 Show FBI Agents Mislead DOJ On The Trump-Russia Investigation

by The Federalist
May 19, 2022
0
Handwritten Notes From 2017 Show FBI Agents Mislead DOJ On The Trump-Russia Investigation
National Security

Hillary Clinton’s campaign lawyer Michael Sussmann is currently on trial for lying to the FBI about his role in pushing...

Read more

Jankowicz Got The Boot, But Biden’s ‘Ministry Of Truth’ Hired Replacements Are WORST

by ThinkCivics Newswire
May 19, 2022
0
Jankowicz Got The Boot, But Biden’s ‘Ministry Of Truth’ Hired Replacements Are WORST
National Security

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) hired the co-author of the PATRIOT Act, arguably the harshest crackdown on civil liberties...

Read more
The Sinister Roots of Build Back Better
Economy

The Sinister Roots of Build Back Better

by American Thinker
May 26, 2022
0

President Joe Biden and the puppeteers who control his teleprompter are weakening the country in order to gain more power...

Read more
Watch: Davos Elites Warn “Painful Global Transition” Should Not Be Resisted By Nation-States
Economy

Watch: Davos Elites Warn “Painful Global Transition” Should Not Be Resisted By Nation-States

by Zero Hedge
May 24, 2022
0

As World Economic Forum head Klaus Schwab proclaimed that “the future is built by us” at the opening of the...

Read more
This Year’s World Economic Forum in Davos Is as Disturbing as You’d Expect
Economy

This Year’s World Economic Forum in Davos Is as Disturbing as You’d Expect

by RedState
May 23, 2022
0

It’s the time of year again when thousands of the world’s most powerful and wealthy people gather in Davos, Switzerland...

Read more
Is Trump A Modern Day Nostradamus? Watch His Prediction Of What Would Happen If Biden Won
Economy

Is Trump A Modern Day Nostradamus? Watch His Prediction Of What Would Happen If Biden Won

by The Political Insider
May 23, 2022
0

President Trump is many things, to friend and foe alike. Is being a modern day Nostradamus among them? At least...

Read more
Facebook Twitter RSS

Brilliantly

SAFE!

thinkcivics.com

Content & Links

Verified by Sur.ly

2022

Recent News

  • Chicago Police Hunt for Man Who Allegedly Pointed Gun at News Crew during Report on Gun Violence
  • Major Companies Line Up to Fund Abortion Tourism after Roe
  • ‘License to Lie’: Prosecutors Claim Sussmann Felt Entitled to Manipulate FBI in Closing Argument

Category

  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Editorials
  • Education
  • Elections
  • Energy
  • Environment
  • Faith
  • Health
  • Immigration
  • Military
  • National Security
  • Politics
  • Science & Tech
  • Uncategorized
  • US News
  • Videos
  • World News

© 2022 ThinkCivics Media. All Rights Reserved.

  • Login
  • Sign Up
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About
  • Store
  • Contact Us
  • Join
  • Contribute

© 2022 ThinkCivics Media. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

OR

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.