• Login
thinkcivics.
Subscribe
Join Us
  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Health & Science
  • News & Politics
  • Religion
  • Technology
  • World
No Result
View All Result
tc.
  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Health & Science
  • News & Politics
  • Religion
  • Technology
  • World
Subscribe
Join Us
No Result
View All Result
thinkcivics.
Home

California City Bans New Gas Stations in Latest Climate Change Effort

Here’s how this unprecedented restriction will backfire.

ThinkCivics Newswire by ThinkCivics Newswire
March 22, 2021
in Health & Science
Reading Time: 4min read
0
0
California City Bans New Gas Stations in Latest Climate Change Effort

Custom Image By FEE | Image Credit: PixaBay

Article Table of Contents hide
1 Why This Regulation Won’t Accomplish Its Goal—And Could Actually INCREASE Emissions
2 Unintended Consequences Always Plague Big Government Interventions

As the debate over climate policy continues to heat up, one California city just took an unprecedented step: Banning all new gas stations.

Our work relies on the support of readers like you. Please consider supporting us at PayPal or Patreon, to help sustain our journalism.

As reported by the San Francisco Chronicle, the city of Petaluma will ban the construction, expansion, rebuilding, and relocating of gas stations after a unanimous vote by the City Council. It does so in hopes of forcibly speeding up the transition to electric cars with the goal of reaching “carbon neutrality,” net-zero carbon emissions, by 2030.

Get Our Weekly Newsletter and Get Smarter

Receive a weekly recap featuring a curated list of must-read stories.

We agree to have my personal information transfered to MailChimp ( more information )

We will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Petaluma has become what officials said is the first city in the country to permanently ban the construction of new gas stations. https://t.co/tbdBBYhStQ

— San Francisco Chronicle (@sfchronicle) March 2, 2021

“We need to do our part to help mitigate and adapt to our changing weather patterns that exist because of all the carbon we put in the atmosphere,” Councilwoman D’lynda Fischer said. “I hope other cities will follow suit and if they have existing fossil fuel stations that satisfy the needs of their community, they too will decide that they don’t need any more.”

“Prohibiting new gas stations serves the public interest by preventing new sources of pollution that adversely impact environmental and human health,” reads the legislation.

Why This Regulation Won’t Accomplish Its Goal—And Could Actually INCREASE Emissions

The goal of this policy is clear. By banning new gas stations, the City Council wants to combat climate change by reducing carbon emissions from driving gas-powered vehicles.

However, the opposite could actually occur. Why?

Well, the only reason new gas stations would be built in Petaluma is if businesses can observe a strong demand for additional gas stations in the area. Banning them from constructing new stations does not eliminate this demand. So, what could end up happening, ironically, is that more emissions are released as Petaluma residents have to drive farther to existing gas stations than they would have had to otherwise, or if they eventually have to start leaving the area to get gas.

Similarly, this law will artificially restrict the supply of gas in Petaluma—meaning that, as basic economics teaches, the price of gas will likely rise significantly. Higher fuel prices disproportionately hurt poorer citizens and strain household budgets.

But from the City Council’s perspective, this might be exactly what they want; hoping higher gas prices will prompt more people to switch to electric cars. However, the higher prices could inadvertently just prompt many people to drive out of town to purchase gas, where prices will remain significantly lower. This seems like a much more realistic and financially feasible adaptation for most people than to purchase entirely new, expensive electric cars.

Moreover, even to the extent that such a ban would encourage people to switch to electric vehicles, it’s unclear this would necessarily mean lower carbon emissions. The extent to which electric vehicles reduce carbon emissions depends on what electricity source is used to power the car. If it’s fossil fuel based—nearly 70 percent of California’s power still comes from non-“renewable” sources—then electric vehicles must still significantly contribute to carbon emissions.

That’s right: All the costs and inconvenience imposed on city residents could be for nothing.

Unintended Consequences Always Plague Big Government Interventions

Unfortunately, this kind of policy dysfunction isn’t exclusive to environmental issues or Petaluma, California. Whenever government bureaucrats huddle together in a City Hall, State Capitol, or even Congress, and try to make sweeping rules for millions of people, drastic unintended consequences will inevitably follow.

“Every human action has both intended and unintended consequences,” economist Antony Davies and political scientist James Harrigan explained for FEE.org. “Human beings react to every rule, regulation, and order governments impose, and their reactions result in outcomes that can be quite different than the outcomes lawmakers intended.”

They dubbed this the “Cobra Effect.”

Davies and Harrigan told the comical yet revealing tale of how an Indian city placed a bounty on cobras to try and solve their infestation problem, yet achieved the opposite result. Why?

At first, more people hunted cobras to get the bounty, and the cobra population decreased. Yet then individuals started breeding and raising cobras at home in order to get the bounty again. When the government cancelled the bounty because the population had seemingly declined, citizens released all the cobras they had been raising in their homes into the wild.

Read: Could Federal Cannabis Legalization Aid in Solving the Opioid Crisis?

The end result was a worse infestation of cobras than the city had to begin with. The farcical outcome brings to mind the words of economist Robert P. Murphy, who wrote for FEE that “It’s not enough… to endorse legislation that has a nice title and promises to do something good… people need to think through the full consequences of a policy, because often it will lead to a cure worse than the disease.”

This timeless principle remains true whether we’re talking about cobras in India or gas stations in California. It’s just a shame Petaluma’s City Council will have to learn this lesson the hard way—while residents pay the price.

Brad Polumbo

Brad Polumbo

Brad Polumbo (@Brad_Polumbo) is a libertarian-conservative journalist and Opinion Editor at the Foundation for Economic Education.

This article was originally published on FEE.org. Read the original article.

ThinkCivics Newswire

ThinkCivics researches, examines, and reports on issues that matter most. We deliver explanative, fearless, and insightful analysis for public consumption.

thinkcivics.com
Tags: CaliforniaCobra effectGas pricesGas station

Related Posts

FEMA Will Provide More Money for Covid Funeral Expenses

FEMA Will Provide More Money for Covid Funeral Expenses

April 7, 2021
Rand Paul Says Health Officials ‘Can’t Stand Good News’ About Pandemic, Tells Americans ‘Go Live Your Life’

Rand Paul Says Health Officials ‘Can’t Stand Good News’ About Pandemic, Tells Americans ‘Go Live Your Life’

April 7, 2021

Gov. DeSantis Slams Controversial ’60 Minutes’ Segment About Vaccine Distribution: ‘They Don’t Believe In Facts’

April 6, 2021

COVID-19 Vaccine Travel Pass to Be Launched on Apple in Mid-April

April 7, 2021
Load More
Next Post
Voting Access Bill Sparks Controversy In Georgia

Civil rights groups urge companies to join fight against Georgia voting restrictions

Can the US Adopt Renewable Energy Sources While Protecting the Electric Grid Against Threats?

Can the US Adopt Renewable Energy Sources While Protecting the Electric Grid Against Threats?

U.S. adds a strong 379,000 jobs in hopeful sign for economy

U.S. adds a strong 379,000 jobs in hopeful sign for economy

Staff Editorials

Governor Brian Kemp Tours Delta Mass Vaccination Site
Culture & Society

Georgia Corporations Cave to Activists On Voter ID Law. Republicans Hit Back Where It Hurts.

by Michael Price, MPA
April 9, 2021
Close Up Of Boxing Gloves
News & Politics

Now Is The Time for America to Make Room for a Third-Party. Voters Deserve Better!

by Samantha DeTurk
April 5, 2021
Vaccine Passports Pose Privacy and Discrimination Concerns Says Health Experts and Digital Privacy Advocates
Health & Science

Vaccine Passports Pose Privacy and Discrimination Concerns Says Health Experts and Digital Privacy Advocates

by Michael Price, MPA
March 29, 2021
Rep. Jackie Speier, House Speaker Pelosi And Congressional Democrats Mark Vote On The Equal Rights Amendment Ratification
Culture & Society

The Left Pushes for Ratification of the ERA with President Biden’s Support

by Josh Herrington
March 25, 2021
The Bipartisan ‘Endless Frontier Act’ Increases Tech Research Spending to $100bn Annually to Outcompete Communist China
Technology

The Bipartisan ‘Endless Frontier Act’ Increases Tech Research Spending to $100bn Annually to Outcompete Communist China

by Keefer Novik
March 24, 2021

Recommended

Homebuyer mortgage demand inches higher, but rates hit highest level since summer

Homebuyer mortgage demand inches higher, but rates hit highest level since summer

3 weeks ago
New York’s wealthiest look for exits as state readies hefty tax increase

New York’s wealthiest look for exits as state readies hefty tax increase

3 days ago
Billy Te Kahika Leads 'Freedom Rally' Outside Parliament

The Great Reset: What Are the Elites Resetting?

2 months ago
$325,000 Settlement for Teacher Over Trump References Removed From Yearbook

$325,000 Settlement for Teacher Over Trump References Removed From Yearbook

3 weeks ago

Categories

  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Editorials
  • Health & Science
  • News & Politics
  • Religion
  • Technology
  • World
No Result
View All Result

Highlights

Biden Admin Considering Cash Payments to Central America to Control Migration

In 5-4 vote, Supreme Court lifts California’s COVID ban on group Bible study in homes

Will Biden ‘Pack’ the Supreme Court?

McConnell Vs. Trump! Warring Wings Of GOP May Face Off In Alaska Senate Race

What Happened to Biden’s Unity Agenda?

Biden’s border czar is stepping down

What's New

‘Critical Race Theory’ Being Taught at US Army’s West Point: Congressman
Culture & Society

‘Critical Race Theory’ Being Taught at US Army’s West Point: Congressman

by ThinkCivics Newswire
April 11, 2021
0

A Republican congressman said he is looking for answers from the U.S. Military Academy West Point about whether...

As protesters on left and right target public servants at home, one city pushes back

As protesters on left and right target public servants at home, one city pushes back

April 11, 2021
Trump Lashes His Enemies Anew as G.O.P. Dances Around His Presence

Trump Lashes His Enemies Anew as G.O.P. Dances Around His Presence

April 11, 2021
Biden Admin Considering Cash Payments to Central America to Control Migration

Biden Admin Considering Cash Payments to Central America to Control Migration

April 10, 2021
In 5-4 vote, Supreme Court lifts California’s COVID ban on group Bible study in homes

In 5-4 vote, Supreme Court lifts California’s COVID ban on group Bible study in homes

April 10, 2021
Facebook Twitter Instagram RSS

Follow us on social media:

About ThinkCivics

We research, examine, and report on issues that matter most. We deliver explanative, fearless, and insightful analysis for public consumption. Our reports are not presented in confusing academic or political language, we speak Main Street English.

Recent News

  • ‘Critical Race Theory’ Being Taught at US Army’s West Point: Congressman
  • As protesters on left and right target public servants at home, one city pushes back
  • Trump Lashes His Enemies Anew as G.O.P. Dances Around His Presence

Category

  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Editorials
  • Health & Science
  • News & Politics
  • Religion
  • Technology
  • World

© 2021 ThinkCivics Media. All Rights Reserved.

  • Login
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About
  • Store
  • Contact Us
  • ThinkCivics Plus
  • Contribute

© 2021 ThinkCivics Media. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.