• Login
thinkcivics.
Subscribe
Join Us
  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Health & Science
  • News & Politics
  • Religion
  • Technology
  • World
No Result
View All Result
tc.
  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Health & Science
  • News & Politics
  • Religion
  • Technology
  • World
Subscribe
Join Us
No Result
View All Result
thinkcivics.
Home News & Politics

Can Democrats Hold Onto Their Senate Majority?

ThinkCivics Newswire by ThinkCivics Newswire
April 7, 2021
in News & Politics
Reading Time: 5min read
0
0
Can Democrats Hold Onto Their Senate Majority?

The Democrats’ twin victories in the Georgia Senate runoffs gave them a tenuous majority. With the upper chamber balanced at 50-50, Democrats’ ability to exert control depends on their ability to hold all of these seats in 2022 (and the vice presidency, which is guaranteed through 2024).

Our work relies on the support of readers like you. Please consider supporting us at PayPal or Patreon, to help sustain our journalism.

Can they do it? History might suggest no. The phenomenon of midterm loss is well-established for the House of Representatives: The president’s party has lost ground in every midterm election dating back to the end of Reconstruction save for three: 1934, 1998 and 2002.  All three of those elections took place in unusual circumstances, where presidents had job approvals approaching or exceeding 70% (we presume this was the case in 1934).

Get Our Weekly Newsletter and Get Smarter

Receive a weekly recap featuring a curated list of must-read stories.

We agree to have my personal information transfered to MailChimp ( more information )

We will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.

In the Senate, however, the record is somewhat more mixed. The president’s party gained seats in 1886, 1898, 1906, 1914, 1934, 1962, 1970, and 2018.  Notably, many of these Senate gains occurred in years that were otherwise rough for the president’s party; Democrats lost 61 House seats in 1914, while Republicans lost 40 in 2018.

The key insight is that not all Senate seats are up in every year, and where those races occur can have a significant impact on the outcome of the election. In 2010, Republicans won every Senate race in states that Barack Obama won by less than nine percentage points (with the exception of Joe Manchin’s run in West Virginia) and were a nomination hiccup in Colorado away from the races in states Obama won by less than 13 points. Had the Senate class of 2012 been up for reelection in 2010, Democratic losses could easily have run into the double digits.

That Senate class was up for reelection in 2018, which partially explains why four Democratic incumbents lost despite the negative environment for Republicans. This is all to say, Senate elections are affected by the national environment, but vagaries of the characteristics of the class that is up in a given year affects outcomes.

What should we expect, then, in 2022? Democrats have no room for error, given their razor-thin majority, but they have one thing going for them: This class hasn’t had a good Democratic year since 1998. Republicans ran well in 2004, and then pushed deeply into Democratic territory in the 2010 midterms. It was thought that Republicans would lose a substantial number of seats in 2016, but the party minimized losses by riding Trump’s coattails.

Put differently, Democrats simply don’t have much exposure this election. Democrats don’t have any incumbents up for reelection in states Trump carried, although two hail from states that narrowly went Joe Biden’s way (Georgia and Arizona). They have two other seats up in states that lean somewhat in the Democrats’ direction (Nevada and New Hampshire) and one in Colorado, which has elected Republicans narrowly in wave years but has since moved in the Democrats’ direction.

Republicans don’t suffer from a massive amount of exposure either, but they do hold seats in two Trump-then-Biden states: Wisconsin and Pennsylvania.  Moreover, the incumbent in Wisconsin, Ron Johnson, has made some controversial statements recently, while the seat in Pennsylvania is open this time. The open seat in North Carolina will likewise be a tough hold, while those in Ohio, Iowa and Florida could come into play with retirements or with a good enough environment for Democrats.

To help sort this out, I’ve employed a model I first used back in 2014. The idea is that we’ve become so polarized that elections are primarily referenda on the party in power, and that senators’ fates are increasingly tied to the fate of the president. If a president of their own party is popular in their state, they will likely win. If he is unpopular, they will likely lose.

It also looks at whether the seat has an incumbent and whether one of the candidates is uniquely problematic (think: Sharron Angle). So, for example, Republicans may nominate candidates who would have a difficult time winning under any circumstance in Georgia or Arizona, depending on how things shake out. As a final note, it only takes into account modestly competitive races, on the theory that “safe” races are effectively drawn from a different distribution (i.e., they are fundamentally different than races that are rated competitive).

The model isn’t intended to get every race correct: It systematically under-predicts Joe Manchin’s chances, for example. The idea is that there will be errors in individual races, but they will tend to cancel out. In other words, it doesn’t shoot for accuracy in particular races so much as it shoots for unbiased-ness.

It has performed well over the years. In 2014, it suggested that if Barack Obama’s job approval were 44% on Election Day then Democrats would lose around nine Senate seats. This is what happened. In 2016, it suggested Democrats would gain three seats if Obama’s job approval were 52% on Election Day; they gained two. In 2018, it said that Republicans would gain a pair of Senate seats if Donald Trump’s job approval hit 45%; that is what happened. In 2020, a 47% presidential job approval translated to a wash; as of Election Day they had lost a seat. The model would also suggest that Republicans’ eventual loss of the Georgia Senate seats in January was mostly a function of Trump’s declining job approval in the interim.

So what does the model see for 2022? Figure 1 shows the outcomes for 10,000 simulated elections across the five seats held by Democrats and seven held by Republicans, based on Biden’s current job approval rating of 52%. It likes the Democrats’ chances of picking up a seat. Perhaps most importantly, they also would have strong likelihood of defending their seats. It would see Pennsylvania and North Carolina as solid pickup opportunities. It might like Ron Johnson’s chances in Wisconsin too much – he arguably should be classified as a “problematic” candidate at this point – but it also might be too bullish on Democrats in North Carolina, given their recent track record there. Likewise, if Christopher Sununu runs for the Senate in New Hampshire, Republican chances would improve there.

Of course, President Biden’s job approval is probably not going to be 52% on Election Day 2022.  It could be higher, or it could be lower. To account for this, I ran 10,000 simulations with his job approval at every level between 37% and 60%, which seem like credible outer bounds for where his rating could wind up.

As you can see, Biden isn’t that far off a job approval where he could see significant gains in the Senate — enough to almost certainly jettison the filibuster and enact a wide-ranging agenda. Just four points higher, at 56%, Democrats would be expected to gain between two and five seats. But he also isn’t that far off a job approval rating where things would go very poorly: If he enters the midterms at 45% — roughly where presidents have been for the last four midterm elections — Democrats would lose between one and four seats, possibly setting Republicans up for a massive Senate majority after the 2024 elections.

The break-even point appears to be around 49%. At that number, we would expect the Senate outcome to be very close, with Republicans roughly as likely to take the Senate as Democrats are to keep it.

Of course, like all models, no one should take this too literally, and (more importantly) the error margins are real. As the great statistician George Box famously put it, “All models are wrong, but some are useful.” The utility here is probably in generating reasonable bounds on our expectations. Democrats probably are favored to retain the Senate for now, but their outcomes are tied to their president’s performance, and they don’t have much room for error.

Read the original article.

ThinkCivics Newswire

ThinkCivics researches, examines, and reports on issues that matter most. We deliver explanative, fearless, and insightful analysis for public consumption.

thinkcivics.com
Tags: AM Update

Related Posts

White House Putting Police Oversight Commission on Hold to Pursue Legislation: Susan Rice

White House Putting Police Oversight Commission on Hold to Pursue Legislation: Susan Rice

April 12, 2021
Top CEOs Met to Discuss Voting Laws Deemed Discriminatory, Limiting

Top CEOs Met to Discuss Voting Laws Deemed Discriminatory, Limiting

April 12, 2021

Putting Biden’s Gun Control Claims To The Truth Test

April 12, 2021

Businesses Taking Political Positions Further Divide The Nation

April 12, 2021
Load More
Next Post
COVID-19 Vaccine Travel Pass to Be Launched on Apple in Mid-April

COVID-19 Vaccine Travel Pass to Be Launched on Apple in Mid-April

President Biden Gets Low Marks For His Handling Of Border Crisis In New Poll

President Biden Gets Low Marks For His Handling Of Border Crisis In New Poll

24% of unemployed workers have been jobless for over a year

24% of unemployed workers have been jobless for over a year

Staff Editorials

Governor Brian Kemp Tours Delta Mass Vaccination Site
Culture & Society

Georgia Corporations Cave to Activists On Voter ID Law. Republicans Hit Back Where It Hurts.

by Michael Price, MPA
April 9, 2021
Close Up Of Boxing Gloves
News & Politics

Now Is The Time for America to Make Room for a Third-Party. Voters Deserve Better!

by Samantha DeTurk
April 5, 2021
Vaccine Passports Pose Privacy and Discrimination Concerns Says Health Experts and Digital Privacy Advocates
Health & Science

Vaccine Passports Pose Privacy and Discrimination Concerns Says Health Experts and Digital Privacy Advocates

by Michael Price, MPA
March 29, 2021
Rep. Jackie Speier, House Speaker Pelosi And Congressional Democrats Mark Vote On The Equal Rights Amendment Ratification
Culture & Society

The Left Pushes for Ratification of the ERA with President Biden’s Support

by Josh Herrington
March 25, 2021
The Bipartisan ‘Endless Frontier Act’ Increases Tech Research Spending to $100bn Annually to Outcompete Communist China
Technology

The Bipartisan ‘Endless Frontier Act’ Increases Tech Research Spending to $100bn Annually to Outcompete Communist China

by Keefer Novik
March 24, 2021

Recommended

Democrat Leaders Welcome MLB All-Star Game to Their States: Georgia Election Law Saga

Democrat Leaders Welcome MLB All-Star Game to Their States: Georgia Election Law Saga

1 week ago
GOP Senator Says Gun Reform Bill Requiring Background Checks Could Get Bipartisan Support

GOP Senator Says Gun Reform Bill Requiring Background Checks Could Get Bipartisan Support

2 weeks ago
Amazon’s Twitch Bans Users Based on Undisclosed ‘Hate Group’ List

Amazon’s Twitch Bans Users Based on Undisclosed ‘Hate Group’ List

8 hours ago
A Complex Website, a Cautious Government: Why New Obamacare Subsidies Will Roll Out Slowly

A Complex Website, a Cautious Government: Why New Obamacare Subsidies Will Roll Out Slowly

3 weeks ago

Categories

  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Editorials
  • Health & Science
  • News & Politics
  • Religion
  • Technology
  • World
No Result
View All Result

Highlights

The third round of stimulus checks helped, but millions of Americans are still struggling

Putting Biden’s Gun Control Claims To The Truth Test

Businesses Taking Political Positions Further Divide The Nation

Amazon’s Twitch Bans Users Based on Undisclosed ‘Hate Group’ List

Iran vows revenge for ‘Israeli’ attack on Natanz nuclear site

The Racist Incident That Wasn’t

What's New

White House Putting Police Oversight Commission on Hold to Pursue Legislation: Susan Rice
News & Politics

White House Putting Police Oversight Commission on Hold to Pursue Legislation: Susan Rice

by ThinkCivics Newswire
April 12, 2021
0

Head of Biden’s Domestic Policy Council, Susan Rice, said the White House has suspended its plans to...

Biden says he is ‘prepared to negotiate’ scope of infrastructure plan and how to pay for it

Biden says he is ‘prepared to negotiate’ scope of infrastructure plan and how to pay for it

April 12, 2021
Top CEOs Met to Discuss Voting Laws Deemed Discriminatory, Limiting

Top CEOs Met to Discuss Voting Laws Deemed Discriminatory, Limiting

April 12, 2021
The third round of stimulus checks helped, but millions of Americans are still struggling

The third round of stimulus checks helped, but millions of Americans are still struggling

April 12, 2021
Putting Biden’s Gun Control Claims To The Truth Test

Putting Biden’s Gun Control Claims To The Truth Test

April 12, 2021
Facebook Twitter Instagram RSS

Follow us on social media:

About ThinkCivics

We research, examine, and report on issues that matter most. We deliver explanative, fearless, and insightful analysis for public consumption. Our reports are not presented in confusing academic or political language, we speak Main Street English.

Recent News

  • White House Putting Police Oversight Commission on Hold to Pursue Legislation: Susan Rice
  • Biden says he is ‘prepared to negotiate’ scope of infrastructure plan and how to pay for it
  • Top CEOs Met to Discuss Voting Laws Deemed Discriminatory, Limiting

Category

  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Editorials
  • Health & Science
  • News & Politics
  • Religion
  • Technology
  • World

© 2021 ThinkCivics Media. All Rights Reserved.

  • Login
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About
  • Store
  • Contact Us
  • ThinkCivics Plus
  • Contribute

© 2021 ThinkCivics Media. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.