ThinkCivics News
An educated citizenry is a vital requisite
for our survival as a free people.
Join ThinkCivics+
  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Health
  • US News
  • Faith
  • Science & Tech
  • World News
No Result
View All Result
ThinkCivics News
  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Health
  • US News
  • Faith
  • Science & Tech
  • World News
Join ThinkCivics+
No Result
View All Result
ThinkCivics News
Join TC+
Home Health

The New York Times Assumes a Scientific Consensus on School Mask Mandates That Its Own Reporting Shows Does Not Exist

Reason.com by Reason.com
August 31, 2021
in Health
Reading Time: 6 mins read
0
0
The New York Times Assumes a Scientific Consensus on School Mask Mandates That Its Own Reporting Shows Does Not Exist

The Department of Education this week announced investigations of five states that have told public schools they may not force students to wear face masks as a safeguard against COVID-19. Because the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has recommended “universal masking” in K–12 schools, Secretary of Education Miguel Cardona says, those states may be violating federal laws that ban discrimination against people with disabilities. Among other things, that argument assumes a nonexistent scientific consensus that mask mandates in schools are a minimum requirement for resuming in-person instruction.

If you are a regular reader of The New York Times, you could be forgiven for thinking that resistance to mask mandates is irrational at best and crassly partisan at worst, sacrificing the safety of children to score cheap political points. “Many states have urged localities to return to in-person schooling while promoting policies that conflict with the goal of educating young people in safety,” the paper lamented in a recent editorial. “As of early August, only 29 states had recommended that students wear masks—down from the 44 states that did so last fall—and nine states had banned masking requirements.” The Times commended President Joe Biden for taking “the right approach” by using the Education Department’s “broad authority” to “deter the states from barring universal masking in classrooms.”

Times columnist Jamelle Bouie cites opposition to school mask mandates by Republicans such as Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis and Texas Gov. Greg Abbott as evidence that Republicans do not “actually want the pandemic to end.” In a Times opinion piece published earlier this month, Duke University pediatrician Kanecia Zimmerman and Danny Benjamin Jr., a pediatric infectious disease specialist at Duke Health, claimed the public health benefits of forcing students to wear masks are well-established, although the evidence they cited was equivocal at best.

The Times even ran an essay in which University of Louisville research psychologist Judith Danovitch took it for granted that all sensible, scientifically informed people recognize that mask mandates are necessary, then proceeded to argue that such requirements have secondary, character-building benefits. They instill self-discipline, she argued, and deter kids from biting their nails or picking their noses.

The pro-mandate position also pervades news coverage of the issue in the Times. Here is the opening sentence of a story published today: “As a new coronavirus wave accelerated by the Delta variant spreads across the United States, many Republican governors have taken sweeping action to combat what they see as an even more urgent danger posed by the pandemic: the threat to personal freedom.” That is a pretty glib way to dismiss the substantial burdens imposed by mask mandates, which add daylong discomfort and anxiety to an environment that was not exactly fun to begin with, distract teachers and students who must enforce and comply with the rule, and interfere with learning, communication, and social interaction.

To its credit, the Times also has made room for dissenting voices, such as Boston University epidemiologist Helen Jenkins and Joseph Allen, director of the healthy buildings program at Harvard’s T.H. Chan School of Public Health. “In Britain the government doesn’t require masks for children in schools,” they note in an essay published yesterday. “Britain has experts, as we do, and they are looking at the same scientific data we are; they most assuredly care about children’s health the same way we do, and yet, they have come to a different policy decision. Schools were prioritized over other activities, and the risks of transmission without masks were considered acceptable.”

Times reporter Dana Goldstein describes the British experience in a recent story with a headline that must have come as a shock to many of the paper’s readers: “In Britain, Young Children Don’t Wear Masks in School.” Contrary to the implication, older students are not required to wear masks either. “Face coverings are no longer advised for pupils, staff and visitors either in classrooms or in communal areas,” the British Department of Education says.

“Under the government guidelines,” Goldstein reports, “masks in classrooms were required only for discrete periods in secondary schools, the equivalent of middle and high school, and were never required for elementary-age children.” And unlike in the United States, where school mask mandates have generated bitter partisan fights, “both the Conservative and Labour Parties have generally believed that face coverings hinder young children’s ability to communicate, socialize and learn.”

Shamez Ladhani, a pediatric infectious-disease specialist at St. George’s Hospital in London, tells Goldstein “the U.K. has always, from the beginning, emphasized they do not see a place for face coverings for children if it’s avoidable.” The costs of forcing children to wear masks exceed the likely benefits, he says, because the ability to see faces is “important for the social development and interaction between people.”

The public health disaster that you might expect based on the position taken by the CDC, the U.S. Education Department, the Times editorial board, and commentators such as Bouie has not transpired in the U.K., Goldstein notes:

It is difficult to pinpoint exactly how much spread occurred on campuses. But throughout the pandemic, government studies showed that infection rates in schools did not exceed those in the community at large, Dr. Ladhani said. In schools that experienced multiple virus cases, he added, there were often “multiple introductions”—meaning that infections were likely acquired outside the building.

There is debate about whether the end of the school year in mid-July contributed to the nation’s drop in virus cases, but some researchers point out that the decline began before schools closed.

Instead of mandating masks, Goldstein says, the British government has “focused on other safety measures,” including rapid testing to identify carriers and quarantining their close contacts. Allen and Jenkins note that the impact of quarantines can be minimized by “allowing kids who test negative to go to in-person class rather than mass quarantining hundreds or thousands of children.”

A randomized study of British secondary schools and colleges, conducted after the emergence of the delta variant, found that strategy was as effective as mass quarantines. “Though the daily testing regimen was challenging for some schools to carry out,” Goldstein says, “the results were reassuring: In both the quarantine and test groups, less than 2 percent of the contacts tested positive for Covid-19.” The researchers concluded that “daily contact testing is a safe alternative to home isolation following school-based exposures.”

The U.K. is by no means unique in eschewing “universal masking” in schools. As David Zweig notes in New York magazine, “many of America’s peer nations around the world—including the U.K., Ireland, all of Scandinavia, France, the Netherlands, Switzerland, and Italy—have exempted kids, with varying age cutoffs, from wearing masks in classrooms” without experiencing more school-related COVID-19 outbreaks than the U.S. has seen.

Allen and Jenkins note that “disease severity for a vast majority of kids is low.” According to the CDC’s “current best estimate,” the infection fatality rate for people younger than 18 is 0.002 percent.

Allen and Jenkins do not take a firm position for or against school mask mandates. But they argue that school districts that decide to require masks need to have a clearer idea of the goal they are trying to reach.

While it might seem reasonable to require masks until COVID-19 vaccines are approved for Americans younger than 12, Allen and Jenkins say, what will happen if the vaccination rate in that group proves to be disappointingly low? “If it’s conceivable—and even likely—that in March most children will still be unvaccinated, does this mean masks should come off then anyway?” they wonder. “Or would masks be recommended indefinitely?”

That disheartening prospect is hardly unrealistic given the views of many local officials, the CDC’s low tolerance for risk, and the Biden administration’s suggestion that the agency’s advice is legally binding. “Any organization setting a mask mandate at this point in the pandemic in the United States must pair that mandate with an offramp plan,” Allen and Jenkins say. “Sleepwalking into indefinite masking is not in anyone’s interests and can increase distrust after an already very difficult year.”

This article was originally published on Reason.com. Read the original article.

Reason.com

Reason is the nation’s leading libertarian magazine. They produce hard-hitting independent journalism on civil liberties, politics, technology, culture, policy, and commerce.

reason.com/
Tags: CDCcoronavirusDepartment of EducationeducationEpidemicsMedia CriticismNew York Timespublic healthpublic schoolsunited kingdom

Related Posts

‘Could Revolutionize Stroke Treatment’: Researchers Discover Breakthrough Treatment For Stroke

‘Could Revolutionize Stroke Treatment’: Researchers Discover Breakthrough Treatment For Stroke

June 30, 2022
Study: Teen cannabis use rose, mental health declined in states with fewer legal restrictions

Study: Teen cannabis use rose, mental health declined in states with fewer legal restrictions

June 28, 2022

Pfizer’s COVID-19 Vaccine Reduces Sperm Count In Men, Study Finds

June 20, 2022

Fauci’s Response to Paul on Royalty Payments Raises Eyebrows

June 17, 2022
Load More
Next Post
40 Ways Things Are Getting Better

40 Ways Things Are Getting Better

Inconclusive intel report on COVID-19 conclusively proved one thing: Censorship is harmful

Inconclusive intel report on COVID-19 conclusively proved one thing: Censorship is harmful

Who Shall Rescue Us from Joe Biden?

Who Shall Rescue Us from Joe Biden?

TODAY'S TOP STORIES

  • American Heart Association issues warning on mRNA vaccines

    American Heart Association issues warning on mRNA vaccines

    2 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • WATCH: Biker kicks car, then what happens next is priceless

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Dem Strategists Get Clocks Cleaned After ‘Report’ About Ron DeSantis Is Debunked by Journalists

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • WATCH: Joey Chestnut Takes Down Protester Before Winning Hot Dog Eating Contest

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Whistleblower: Nearly 50,000 Medicare patients died soon after getting Vaccine

    1 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

‘Zero Trust in Our Government’: Spouse of WNBA Player Jailed in Russia Blasts Biden Administration

by ThinkCivics Newswire
June 22, 2022
0
‘Zero Trust in Our Government’: Spouse of WNBA Player Jailed in Russia Blasts Biden Administration
National Security

Joe Biden's ineptitude knows no bounds. As Obama famously said, "Don't underestimate Joe's ability to f*ck things up." So it's...

Read more

State Dept ‘racial equity’ czar said white colleagues too ‘protective of US, lack ‘humility, empathy’

by ThinkCivics Newswire
June 21, 2022
0
State Dept ‘racial equity’ czar said white colleagues too ‘protective of US, lack ‘humility, empathy’
National Security

A 2020 podcast episode with Desirée Cormier Smith resurfaced after the U.S. State Department appointed her on Friday to serve...

Read more

More countries looking at nuclear weapons programs because of Russia

by Hot Air
June 21, 2022
0
More countries looking at nuclear weapons programs because of Russia
National Security

Over the past year, we have seen multiple nations including the United States conducting tests of their nuclear-capable weapons delivery...

Read more

22 Democrats who voted against extra security for SCOTUS justices approved it for themselves after Jan 6

by ThinkCivics Newswire
June 15, 2022
0
22 Democrats who voted against extra security for SCOTUS justices approved it for themselves after Jan 6
National Security

Ahead of the highly anticipated decision that could overturn Roe v Wade, the House passed a bill on Tuesday to...

Read more
3 Reasons To Use Store Financing for Furniture
Economy

3 Reasons To Use Store Financing for Furniture

by ThinkCivics News Staff
July 6, 2022
0

Buying new furniture can get expensive, especially when you’re trying to furnish an entire room. Many furniture stores offer their...

Read more
Red States Leave Blue States Eating Their Economic Dust in the Post-Pandemic World
Economy

Red States Leave Blue States Eating Their Economic Dust in the Post-Pandemic World

by RedState
July 5, 2022
0

Red states –those that lean Republican—are performing better economically and gaining more residents than blue states, where economic performance lags...

Read more
A Rare Paradigm Shift With Huge Implications… 5 Reasons Why It’s Imminent
Economy

A Rare Paradigm Shift With Huge Implications… 5 Reasons Why It’s Imminent

by ThinkCivics Newswire
July 5, 2022
0

Although many don’t realize it, interest rates are simply the price of money. And they are the most important prices...

Read more
Karine Jean-Pierre Throws Hissy Fit at Jeff Bezos for Blasting Bidenomics
Economy

Karine Jean-Pierre Throws Hissy Fit at Jeff Bezos for Blasting Bidenomics

by RedState
July 3, 2022
0

Welp, this one started out bad — and quickly swirled down the White House personal-attack toilet. Zillionaire Amazon founder and...

Read more
Facebook Twitter RSS

Brilliantly

SAFE!

thinkcivics.com

Content & Links

Verified by Sur.ly

2022

Recent News

  • Chris Rufo leaves Marc Lamont Hill SPEECHLESS with perfect response to racist question
  • AZ GOP Candidate Drops Amazing Ad on Second Amendment That Has Dems Fuming
  • The Mother of All Ads Drops After Gavin Newsom Burns Money Attacking Ron DeSantis

Category

  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Editorials
  • Education
  • Elections
  • Energy
  • Environment
  • Faith
  • Health
  • Immigration
  • Military
  • National Security
  • Politics
  • Science & Tech
  • US News
  • Videos
  • World News

© 2022 ThinkCivics Media. All Rights Reserved.

  • Login
  • Sign Up
  • Cart
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About
  • Store
  • Contact Us
  • Join
  • Contribute

© 2022 ThinkCivics Media. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

OR

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.