• Login
thinkcivics.
Subscribe
Join Us
  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Health & Science
  • News & Politics
  • Religion
  • Technology
  • World
No Result
View All Result
tc.
  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Health & Science
  • News & Politics
  • Religion
  • Technology
  • World
Subscribe
Join Us
No Result
View All Result
thinkcivics.
Home Health & Science

Vaccine Passports Pose Privacy and Discrimination Concerns Says Health Experts and Digital Privacy Advocates

Many health experts and human rights advocates are raising concerns that digital credentialing presents an ethical issue.

Michael Price, MPA by Michael Price, MPA
March 29, 2021
in Health & Science, Editorials
Reading Time: 6min read
0
0
Vaccine Passports Pose Privacy and Discrimination Concerns Says Health Experts and Digital Privacy Advocates

Credit: Shutterstock

Article Table of Contents hide
1 Key Takeaways
2 What State Governors Are Saying
3 Privacy and Information Security Concerns
4 Discriminates Against Disadvantaged Populations
5 Why this Matters

Key Takeaways

  • There are three vaccine passports (or digital health passports) in the works from IBM, CommonPass, and the International Air Transportation Association (IATA).
  • Vaccine passports are seen as the key to reopening state economies.
  • Many health experts and human rights advocates are raising concerns that digital credentialing presents an ethical issue.

Approximately 14 percent of Americans have been fully vaccinated against COVID-19 (SARS-CoV-2). Many experts estimate that to reach the threshold for ‘herd immunity’, 60-70 percent of the population would need to gain immunity through past exposure or vaccinations.

Our work relies on the support of readers like you. Please consider supporting us at PayPal or Patreon, to help sustain our journalism.

After almost a year since the United States went into quarantine, wearing masks, social-distancing, and nasal swabs, there seems to be a glimmer of hope on the horizon. As more of the U.S. population is eligible to receive vaccinations, there have been broader discussions on how to safely reopen the economy to include group events, lessen restrictions on traveling and tourism.  

Get Our Weekly Newsletter and Get Smarter

Receive a weekly recap featuring a curated list of must-read stories.

We agree to have my personal information transfered to MailChimp ( more information )

We will never give away, trade or sell your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.

However, to ensure individuals are safe to gather in groups after being vaccinated, many airlines, concert halls, and other public places are leaning towards requiring proof of immunity. A vaccine passport is an electronic record showing that an individual had either been vaccinated or tested negative for COVID-19.

The variety of passports under development are either digital records or an app on your smartphone. There are three vaccine passports (or digital health passports) in the works from IBM, CommonPass, and the International Air Transportation Association (IATA), which are all similar.

What State Governors Are Saying

Vaccine passports are seen as the key to reopening state economies. Many state governors are open to the concept of vaccine passports but are looking to the CDC for guidance on the value of implementation in their states. 

On CNBC’s Squawk Box, when asked about vaccine passports, NJ Governor Phil Murphy replied: “And in terms of what value that card will have, other than your own personal health, (is) to be determined. But that is under consideration, and there are lots of different potential uses for that, whether it’s going to a sporting event, getting on a plane, etc. So hold onto it and, again, we will first and foremost take our guidance from the CDC.”

Nevertheless, vaccine passports are being heavily politicized. The Republican Governors Associated slammed the New Jersey governor on Twitter, raising that requiring vaccine passports could open the door to a “health privacy minefield.” 

“Governor @PhilMurphyNJ‘s suggestion that Garden Staters could be required to show proof of vaccine is a health privacy minefield.” 💥https://t.co/0d0O3Zh5To

— The RGA (@The_RGA) March 21, 2021

Not surprisingly, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, an anti-lockdown Republican, has said his state won’t be “doing any vaccine passports,” calling the existence of such documents as “unacceptable.” 

Privacy and Information Security Concerns

The electronic nature of the proposed vaccine passports is without controversy among human rights activists and data protection advocates. 

The first issue relates to privacy. The digital nature of the proposed vaccine passports increases the risk of “data breaches” when storing private health information in such a format. According to the leading digital privacy organization, Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) argues:

“[R]equiring people to store their medical test results in a digital format would expose private medical information to the danger of data breaches. Again, this is hardly new—we have seen exactly these types of breaches in the past when medical information has been digitized and collected.”

For example, in 2019, an HIV database in Singapore containing private information was leaked on more than 14,000 individuals who were HIV positive. In the United States, there have been significant data breaches making headlines involving Yahoo, Facebook, Twitter, Google’s Gmail, and Equifax. Past data breaches pose substantial challenges in gaining the public’s trust that their private health information is secure. 

So far, there have been no proposed solutions to ensure private health information stored digitally on the vaccine passports is secured from potential future data breaches. 

Discriminates Against Disadvantaged Populations

Many health experts and human rights advocates are raising concerns that digital credentialing presents an ethical issue. Their problem is digital health passports could “discriminate against disadvantaged populations.” As we plan on reopening our economy, we do not want to overlook inequality of access when it comes to the COVID-19 vaccine, testing, and smartphone technology. 

The EFF argues that using smartphone-based vaccine passports to access public places would risk creating “a two-tiered system that bars people who can’t work, shop or attend school because they don’t have a cell phone or access to testing.”

According to Pew Research, 81% of Americans own smartphones. Parsing out demographic usage, 53% of those 65 and older do not own a smartphone. Among ethnic groups, 79% of Hispanics do not own a smartphone, and whites and blacks have near equal ownership of smartphones (82% and 80%, respectively). By contrast, the most significant disparity is among rural (71%) and suburban (83%) populations. 

Read: What You Need to Know About Endocrine Disrupting Chemicals and Your Health

The lack of widespread ownership of smartphone technology is an issue policymaker and commercial enterprises need to consider when implementing digital vaccine passports. It would be both unethical and unfair to restrict access to public places due to a lack of smartphone technology access to prove immunity. 

Lamenting the concerns with vaccine passports, Dr. Nita Farahany, who is a Duke University professor and a leading scholar on ethical, legal, and social implications of emerging technologies, points out, trust in healthcare and health institutions is “very low right now” by minority populations, and “vaccine passports could further erode trust.” 

Why this Matters

Vaccine passports are supposedly intended to help combat the spread of COVID-19. However, there is little evidence that they would accomplish this. The inequality of access and privacy concerns when it comes to storing health information digitally should concern policymakers and the private sector. 

The private sector has the right to implement vaccine passports as a requirement of access to ensure public safety. However, they would be inadvertently discriminating against disadvantaged populations who do not have access to smartphone technology and overlooking the privacy concerns expressed by leading advocates. 

Now that vaccines are becoming widely available to the general public, there is growing pressure to reopen the economy, but this does not outweigh ethical and privacy concerns of implementing vaccine passports. 

Michael Price, MPA

Mike Price is the founder and Managing Editor of ThinkCivics. He holds a BA in political science and a master’s degree in public administration from Northern Kentucky University. He has been writing about politics, government, and culture for over a decade. When he is not writing about politics, he writes about his faith over on his Christian men’s blog Joshua’s Outpost. Follow him on Twitter at @MPriceMPA or contact him at mjprice83@gmail.com

joshuasoutpost.com/
Tags: CDCCovid-19DiscriminationEthicalInformation SecurityNita FarahanyPhil MurphyPrivacyRon DeSantisSmartphones

Related Posts

FEMA Will Provide More Money for Covid Funeral Expenses

FEMA Will Provide More Money for Covid Funeral Expenses

April 7, 2021
Rand Paul Says Health Officials ‘Can’t Stand Good News’ About Pandemic, Tells Americans ‘Go Live Your Life’

Rand Paul Says Health Officials ‘Can’t Stand Good News’ About Pandemic, Tells Americans ‘Go Live Your Life’

April 7, 2021

Gov. DeSantis Slams Controversial ’60 Minutes’ Segment About Vaccine Distribution: ‘They Don’t Believe In Facts’

April 6, 2021

COVID-19 Vaccine Travel Pass to Be Launched on Apple in Mid-April

April 7, 2021
Load More
Next Post
The Bipartisan Senate Bill You Haven’t Heard About

The Bipartisan Senate Bill You Haven't Heard About

How GOP Support for Reparations Could Save America

How GOP Support for Reparations Could Save America

GOP Senator Says Gun Reform Bill Requiring Background Checks Could Get Bipartisan Support

GOP Senator Says Gun Reform Bill Requiring Background Checks Could Get Bipartisan Support

Staff Editorials

Governor Brian Kemp Tours Delta Mass Vaccination Site
Culture & Society

Georgia Corporations Cave to Activists On Voter ID Law. Republicans Hit Back Where It Hurts.

by Michael Price, MPA
April 9, 2021
Close Up Of Boxing Gloves
News & Politics

Now Is The Time for America to Make Room for a Third-Party. Voters Deserve Better!

by Samantha DeTurk
April 5, 2021
Vaccine Passports Pose Privacy and Discrimination Concerns Says Health Experts and Digital Privacy Advocates
Health & Science

Vaccine Passports Pose Privacy and Discrimination Concerns Says Health Experts and Digital Privacy Advocates

by Michael Price, MPA
March 29, 2021
Rep. Jackie Speier, House Speaker Pelosi And Congressional Democrats Mark Vote On The Equal Rights Amendment Ratification
Culture & Society

The Left Pushes for Ratification of the ERA with President Biden’s Support

by Josh Herrington
March 25, 2021
The Bipartisan ‘Endless Frontier Act’ Increases Tech Research Spending to $100bn Annually to Outcompete Communist China
Technology

The Bipartisan ‘Endless Frontier Act’ Increases Tech Research Spending to $100bn Annually to Outcompete Communist China

by Keefer Novik
March 24, 2021

Recommended

Vaccine Passports Would Be a Draconian Disaster

Vaccine Passports Would Be a Draconian Disaster

2 weeks ago
US-VATICAN-RELIGION-POPE

The Congressional Executive Commission on China Calls for Diplomatic Engagement Between the US and the Vatican

3 months ago
Arizona Governor Rips Kamala Harris – ‘Worst Possible Choice’ For Handling Border Crisis

Arizona Governor Rips Kamala Harris – ‘Worst Possible Choice’ For Handling Border Crisis

2 weeks ago
Nancy Pelosi Holds Her Weekly Press Conference At The U.S. Capitol

Democrats Seek to Radically Transform American Politics With H.R. 1, For the People Act

1 month ago

Categories

  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Editorials
  • Health & Science
  • News & Politics
  • Religion
  • Technology
  • World
No Result
View All Result

Highlights

Biden Admin Considering Cash Payments to Central America to Control Migration

In 5-4 vote, Supreme Court lifts California’s COVID ban on group Bible study in homes

Will Biden ‘Pack’ the Supreme Court?

McConnell Vs. Trump! Warring Wings Of GOP May Face Off In Alaska Senate Race

What Happened to Biden’s Unity Agenda?

Biden’s border czar is stepping down

What's New

‘Critical Race Theory’ Being Taught at US Army’s West Point: Congressman
Culture & Society

‘Critical Race Theory’ Being Taught at US Army’s West Point: Congressman

by ThinkCivics Newswire
April 11, 2021
0

A Republican congressman said he is looking for answers from the U.S. Military Academy West Point about whether...

As protesters on left and right target public servants at home, one city pushes back

As protesters on left and right target public servants at home, one city pushes back

April 11, 2021
Trump Lashes His Enemies Anew as G.O.P. Dances Around His Presence

Trump Lashes His Enemies Anew as G.O.P. Dances Around His Presence

April 11, 2021
Biden Admin Considering Cash Payments to Central America to Control Migration

Biden Admin Considering Cash Payments to Central America to Control Migration

April 10, 2021
In 5-4 vote, Supreme Court lifts California’s COVID ban on group Bible study in homes

In 5-4 vote, Supreme Court lifts California’s COVID ban on group Bible study in homes

April 10, 2021
Facebook Twitter Instagram RSS

Follow us on social media:

About ThinkCivics

We research, examine, and report on issues that matter most. We deliver explanative, fearless, and insightful analysis for public consumption. Our reports are not presented in confusing academic or political language, we speak Main Street English.

Recent News

  • ‘Critical Race Theory’ Being Taught at US Army’s West Point: Congressman
  • As protesters on left and right target public servants at home, one city pushes back
  • Trump Lashes His Enemies Anew as G.O.P. Dances Around His Presence

Category

  • Culture & Society
  • Economy
  • Editorials
  • Health & Science
  • News & Politics
  • Religion
  • Technology
  • World

© 2021 ThinkCivics Media. All Rights Reserved.

  • Login
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About
  • Store
  • Contact Us
  • ThinkCivics Plus
  • Contribute

© 2021 ThinkCivics Media. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.